Poll for The Parts in the Sum of the Whole

Please rate and then tell why you rated it what you did!

I really do think it all came togethere here- acting, writing, directing. It was a 10!

I rated it a 9 only because of Brennan's dress choice in present day. That hideous yellow one. I did not like it.

I gave it a 9 simply because that last scene made me cry TWICE and that's just not cool

8. for 2 reasons...

A: cuz some parts didn't fit, like how Cam said they met, and in "The Titian on the Tracks", they both said that they didn't know each other... and a few more...

B: Brennan's choice at the end. [Only admins are allowed to see this image]

10 because it flowed from beginning to end. And the end was well, just heartbreaking. Sweets was awesome and him telling Booth to tell Brennan (in his own words) how Booth feels about her was priceless.
I didn't think at first it was a 10 but after a second viewing, I changed my mind.

I rate it a 9 I'm saving 10 for the episode they finally get together But I really think this episode replaced Judas as my favorite....

SnoopGirl wrote:10 because it flowed from beginning to end. And the end was well, just heartbreaking. Sweets was awesome and him telling Booth to tell Brennan (in his own words) how Booth feels about her was priceless.
I didn't think at first it was a 10 but after a second viewing, I changed my mind.

It gets better with every viewing right?

19ana89 wrote:8. for 2 reasons...

A: cuz some parts didn't fit, like how Cam said they met, and in "The Titian on the Tracks", they both said that they didn't know each other... and a few more...

B: Brennan's choice at the end. [Only admins are allowed to see this image]

I don't remember either Cam or Brennan saying they never met each other before, but I haven't watched in a while. I'll get back to you LOL

9 because everything was absolutely fantastic acting, directing, storyline and then there was the outome at the end that makes me cry everytime

it deff does get better with each viewing. i think the first time i was too busy freaking out over the plot points to really pay attention to the awesome bb interactions.

There is actually a decent amount of people on Facebook who hated it and think it's the worst thing ever. I'm a tad surprised because aside from that last scene....the flashback was brilliant. it added so much to these characters.

I gave it a 10. Who cares about all the silly little things so many people seem to be obsessed with.

I LOVED it! I've watched the last scene so many times... I don't even know!

I rate it a 100, I don't care about minor inconsistencies even so Brennen never remembers anyone like the fireman in titan on the tracks. I think it is very believable that Brennens character would be so afraid, Emily makes a good point about her fear in her Zap2it interview. The acting in this episode was award worthy.....

Sorry folks, it's a great episode but it's a 9.


RM

I chose a 10 because I thought this was one of the best episodes ever. I thought the acting that David and Emily did was breathtaking, I actually think I stopped breathing for a while. The tears and the looks on their faces in that last scene made me completely speechless. I thought the story fit right with the pilot episode and of course I watched it before and after the 100th episode. I loved this so much

Ha, we really like extremes, don't we. Either 10 or 1. Though I would like the people who vote 1 to explain why they did it.

I gave it a ten. Because for me it's in the line with Verdict, Judas, Aliens...

But I have to say that I hate Emily's hair in that last scene. Maybe they should take a close look at her hair stylist's Curriculum Vitae and credentials again...

10.
Because it was perfect. The writing was extraordinary, Emily, David and John were absolutely fantastic. It flowed, in every way, cut the flashback scenes together, and they would flow perfectly into the pilot.

Obviously I was heartbroken at the end, but HH is still the god of television.

I gave it a 10. It was fantastic, they played it off so well and even the outcome fits. I loved it !

i_heart_bones wrote:10.
Because it was perfect. The writing was extraordinary, Emily, David and John were absolutely fantastic. It flowed, in every way, cut the flashback scenes together, and they would flow perfectly into the pilot.

Obviously I was heartbroken at the end, but HH is still the god of television.

My thoughts exactly. There are no words for how much I love this episode.

LOVED IT!!!
and as far as the cam saying she did not know bones in titan, it actually fits for these reasons

-Bones doesn't remember her, why would embarrass herself by saying she knew her
-she could have wanted to make a better impression, i mean the first time they met Bones was rude, so if Cam pretends she doesn't remember her, she can not only make a better impression but she can be a total b**** as well, kinda like pay back!
- She didn't want to be shut down again, Bones was rude so best thing is to lie ad forget about it.

so i say 10000, but i guess i can only give it a ten!

It deserves a 10!!! It was well-acted, funny, serious when it was needed, well-written, breathtaking during the past kiss, heartcrushing in the moments "can we still work together?".... Amazing!
I have seen this episode too much times since Thusday (because of the time difference with USA and Canada, I could read first opinions on Thursday morning but I watched it later, around 19pm!)... and I still love it!
P.S. I have just notice the smile on Booth's, Bones' and Sweets' faces when Booth asked Cam about the name of that antropologist and she answers... "Temperance Brennan"! It was so perfect!!

THX1138 wrote:Sorry folks, it's a great episode but it's a 9.
I teetered between 9 and 10 but after watching the ending again, it got a 10. With the ending and Sweets taking on Booth's feelings (in front of Brennan!) those two scenes alone are 10's in my opinion.
RM

I teetered between 9 and 10 but after watching the ending again, it got a 10. With the ending and Sweets taking on Booth's feelings (in front of Brennan!) those two bumped it to a 10.

SnoopGirl wrote:

THX1138 wrote:Sorry folks, it's a great episode but it's a 9.

RM

I teetered between 9 and 10 but after watching the ending again, it got a 10. With the ending and Sweets taking on Booth's feelings (in front of Brennan!) those two bumped it to a 10.

I just can't agree. I'd rate a 10 any episode I seriously think can be called the BEST of the season. In Season 4 for me that was Conman - for all the problems I have with their portrayal of Brennan in that ep, it was THE BEST episode of the season.

So far as good as this episode was, it doesn't beat "The Goop on the Girl" - it ties it, but it's not better. I think folks are blinded by the kiss in the past, and the bitter sweet ending. The show was good, on part with Goop, but it doesn't beat it - not IMO. So solid 9.4, but not a 10. I will make this prediction though - the Finale? That will be a 10.

RM

10 cos there are other episodes I'd rate 9, and this one just knocks em outta the park. How can anyone vote 1?!

THX1138 wrote:

SnoopGirl wrote:

THX1138 wrote:Sorry folks, it's a great episode but it's a 9.

RM

I teetered between 9 and 10 but after watching the ending again, it got a 10. With the ending and Sweets taking on Booth's feelings (in front of Brennan!) those two bumped it to a 10.

I just can't agree. I'd rate a 10 any episode I seriously think can be called the BEST of the season. In Season 4 for me that was Conman - for all the problems I have with their portrayal of Brennan in that ep, it was THE BEST episode of the season.

So far as good as this episode was, it doesn't beat "The Goop on the Girl" - it ties it, but it's not better. I think folks are blinded by the kiss in the past, and the bitter sweet ending. The show was good, on part with Goop, but it doesn't beat it - not IMO. So solid 9.4, but not a 10. I will make this prediction though - the Finale? That will be a 10.

RM

I hope the has has physic powers (re: the finale!)